Early on people try to pay
That is absolutely game winning levels of lore collection for turn Five
However, because the counters are removed, it is difficult (but not impossible) to make multiple players lose the game from this ability in the same combat phase
I think even a single target Replenish would put serious constraints on the format and the types of designs WotC could safely make
Categories Magic the Gathering Magic - Boosters, Displays & Other Sealed Magic - Decks (Commander, Challenger, Theme, Intro, Starter, Duel, etc.) Magic - Single Cards Magic - Complete Sets Magic - Miscellaneous Magic - Kunst (Original Art & Paintings) Magic - Merchandise Pokemon Cards Yu-Gi-Oh
Players have been complaining about the card online for months at this point, and eventually, that erodes buyer confidence